Welcome to Mi Estrella Bakery
At Mi Estrella Bakery, the love and passion for baking shine through every dessert. Nestled in Brooklyn, they specialize in custom cakes and cupcakes, particularly their renowned tres leches cake, hailed as the best in the area. With a commitment to quality, their creations are consistently moist, flavorful, and generously portioned, making them a treat perfect for celebrations. The friendly staff adds a personal touch, creating a warm atmosphere that beckons sweet lovers to return. Offering takeout and delivery, Mi Estrella Bakery is more than just a bakery—it's a community gem where every bite feels like a heartfelt celebration.
Mi Estrella Bakery: Reviews & Ratings
the best tres leches cake in all of Brooklyn!! Made my birthday so special with their kindness and you can tell they truly have a love and passion for making their desserts!
Came here to get their flan. W flan fr it had me creaming all over the place. I highly recommend will come back again
Great tasting cake... tres leches is the way to go. Nice and moist and great customer service
Might be the best tres leches / secret gem in NYC - their cakes are super moist and just enough level of sweetness
I've randomly tasked myself with finding the best tres leches in my neighborhood, and this bakery was highly recommended to me by someone who has lived here for 25 years. Firstly, the staff is super nice and the first time I walked in (I've been here three times in the last week), the guy at the counter said that whoever recommended me is probably a frequent visitor because once you try the cakes, it's hard to quit (where is the lie?). Anyway, like I said, I've been back multiple times because now I want to try ALL their flavors. So far, I've had their vanilla, guava, peach, chocoflan, and oreo. All were delicious, although I definitely favor the vanilla cake based ones more, as they seem to soak up the milks better. Additionally, the portions are HUGE for the price. Most slices are about $4 (Cash only by the way) and can easily be shared between 2-3 people. There's not much else to this bakery besides tres leches (i think they make flan), which means they are pretty damn good at making it. I definitely recommend.
We were so happy with our birthday cake for our son's first birthday. It was exactly as we ordered it and it tasted DELICIOUS. Also, the staff was super nice. Can't wait to order another one. Nos encantó! Muchísimas gracias! :)
This spot is a lifesaver! They have a large supply of tresleche cakes in many flavors. Found myself in a pinch for a party and walked in and I was pleasantly surprised...... And the cake was delicious
Came by from a recommendation from another baker for a tres leches cake. Super quaint family business. Took a risk for my wife's birthday cake and we were all super impressed. Will shop here again!
Yum their tres leches was phenominal bought 2 in a month will be going back for a third
Location
-
268 Wyckoff Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237 Hotline: (718) 628-9250
Welcome to Mi Estrella Bakery, a sparkling gem nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 268 Wyckoff Ave. This charming bakery specializes in custom cakes and cupcakes, offering an array of delicious delights that leave a lasting impression. For those seeking the perfect treat, this bakery is known particularly for its tres leches cake—a rich and moist delicacy that has garnered rave reviews from the local community.
What sets Mi Estrella Bakery apart is not just the incredible flavor, but the genuine passion and warmth from the staff. As customer keara c. beautifully puts it, it’s "the best tres leches cake in all of Brooklyn!!" You can feel the love that goes into each dessert they create, making milestones like birthdays even more special.
- Signature Treats: The tres leches cake isn’t simply recommended; it’s consistently highlighted as a must-try. Others rave about the flan, which customer Juicy M. boldly claims had him “creaming all over the place.” If you visit, don’t miss out on these stars of the menu.
- Generous Portions: Many have expressed that the size of the portions is impressive, often enough to be shared among friends or family. Customer Merly M. noted that a typical slice for just $4 can easily be enjoyed by two to three people.
- Accessibility & Services: Whether you’re in the mood for delivery, takeout, or looking for a place that caters, Mi Estrella Bakery has you covered. They are wheelchair accessible and offer bike parking for those who want to indulge after a long ride.
Their cakes, particularly the vanilla and guava variations, have been described as incredibly moist with just the right level of sweetness—making each bite a perfect balance of flavor. Customer Emizz Z. even deemed it “the best tres leches / secret gem in NYC.”
If you’re looking to dive into a world of delightful desserts, Mi Estrella Bakery is where your search ends. With fast and friendly service, you’ll find yourself wanting to return time and again just as Merly M. describes, “once you try the cakes, it’s hard to quit.” So, whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply treating yourself, make sure Mi Estrella Bakery is on your list. Your taste buds will thank you!
To learn more, or to place an order, give them a call at (718) 628-9250. Enjoy your sweet adventure at Mi Estrella Bakery!
